I somehow had never heard this piece until just now. I'm ambivalent of Ives' use of popular songs and melodies in his compositions but America the Beautiful works well as a series of variations, in this case performed on piano. It's on a CD Patriotism, Diversity, and the Pioneer Spirt: An Introduction to the 19th- and Early 20-Centruy American Music along with Stephen Foster, Scott Joplin (played by Roger Shields), Copland's Fanfare for the Common Man, etc. There are no liner notes and looking at the back of the CD, this must be a re-packaging of recordings on Vox.
I'll also link to the recent NY Times article "A Slice of Americana with a Big Scoop of Ives," where Anne Midgette reviews works by Marcus Maroney (blog here), Anna Weesner, Ingram Marshall, and David Rakowski:
The concert was called "Out-of-Towners," but it could have been called "Americana for Our Time." It consisted of new and recent work by four
non-New York American composers performed by members of the St. Luke's
Chamber Ensemble. (Held on Saturday afternoon at the Chelsea Art
Museum, it was the last in the group's "Second Helpings" series.) Its
loudest statement was "Charles Ives lived" - the pieces, while not
exactly derivative of Ives, were certainly evocative of him.
I'll also quote from a rather creative blog post by Bob Merkin where he, among other ideas, talks about good prospects for the music of Ives:
Ives would give the bitter angry Yankee finger to American Patriotism at this sad and pathetic moment in America. Thank God for the Future. Ives, with Sinclair's dedicated and brilliant creative assistance, has a chance to bring true and the best Patriotism -- Lincoln's, Jefferson's, Col. Shaw's -- back to the hearts of Americans gathered around the parlor piano. The flatscreen High Def TV will increasingly be: OFF as America learns again to sing The Songs Our Fathers Loved. I do so wish I had studied the piano. But I can sing Ives, in the Parlor, in the shower.
oh the PEOPLE! NOT!
the politicians goddam thieves
He also rants on the use/misuse of the American flag in the name of patriotism. Although I display the flag for holidays and see that flickr American flag photo feed everyday (picture of an American flag in an English phone booth here), I also downplay the patriotic aspect on the aworks site -- no red/white/blue color theme nor even any flag. Given that up to half of aworks readers are not from the US, I figure they don't need an emphatic display of American boosterism (even if I am subtly advocating for American music). Still, I do take the American flag seriously, and I think it is partly because as a child, I would visit my Uncle on Memorial Day in Indiana (while my Dad and brother would attend the Indy 500, I was too young), and help him place American flags on graves of veterans.
And with respect to Merkin's high def tv comment, we all celebrate patriotism in our own way. Since I have no high-def tv to turn off and I certainly can't sing and there is no one around this morning who deserves "the finger," instead I'm off to SF to see if I can find a CD of band arrangements of Ives' music. A genuinely patriotic activity even if not particularly authentic...
Good program notes of Variations on "America" here:
From the perspective of Ives's later work, Variations on
"America" stands out for its decorous, almost pedantic good
behavior. This may seem a strange assertion, given its rather cavalier
treatment of the main theme, a melody sacrosanct even in Ives's
day. But compared to the boldly experimental approach to musical form
characteristic of all of his mature work, this piece, with its clear
invocation of the centuries-old structure of introduction, theme, and
variations seems positively reactionary